All the hubbub about the Republican vice presidential nominee, while entertaining, may have greater significance that we cannot appreciate in the middle of a very competitive campaign. I am confident that no one, including John McCain and Sarah Palin herself, thinks the governor of Alaska is ready to be the leader of the free world, at least not in the way the public conceives of that job. She is, however, plenty capable of being the Republican president of the United States. None of her embarrassing gaffes to date have been any more frightening than those routinely committed by George W. Bush, and while his tenure has been a bad one, the significant failures (and successes) of the last eight years are primarily the result of his political philosophy, not his character or intellect.In reality, the person behind the big desk in the "oval" neither rules the world nor runs the government all alone. Judging presidential candidates like CEO's whose style and judgment will permeate the government and the policy making process is a joke. Truman's sincere claim about where the buck stops is a powerful fiction. I understand that it might be comforting to think that the failures of government could be pinned on bad elected leaders, but in reality failure and success in high level American politics is ideological and institutional, not personal. In fact, given our creed and our Constitution, it is quite ironic that average Americans invest so much power and authority in the president.
The folks who run the White House now and those who would do so in a McCain-Palin administration have undoubtedly vetted Palin in the most important way. They have confidence that she shares their ideological approach to governance, their broad values and vision, and most importantly SHE WILL DO AS SHE IS TOLD! This does not mean she is stupid, or just a pawn. It means that she is actually what the Republicans say she is, a tough, smart, women who understands her role. She has signed up to play on a team, not to go it alone. All the hand ringing and gallows humor about Palin is grounded in a fundamental misunderstanding about the relative significance of people and partisan ideology in running the government.
That Americans see everything in personal terms is an artifact of our cultural evolution. While there was never a time when Americans judged politics purely based on rational ideas of self interest or right and wrong, the explosion of academic and popular work on the so-called "dumbing down of America" is resonating for a reason. Today the ratio between our rational and non-rational decisional criteria in politics is tilted decisively in favor of the latter. It's as if the Enlightenment, or Age of Reason, has a shelf life and we are nearing its end. The application of this thesis to politics and civic knowledge in America is, however, fraught with contradictions that need sorting out that cannot be accomplished here.
The point is that Palin is a committed conservative, making her the important half of the ticket for rational conservative voters. For non-ideological voters, her apparent lack of sophistication is a problem, but really only because they don't realize how little individual capacities matter in determining public policy. For liberals, her gaffes are merely opportunities to discredit her with non-ideological voters and dampen the moral of ideological conservatives. For ideological voters who do not fit in either party, Palin is just a distraction from the task of choosing which party is more likely to advance their ideological priorities.